Thursday, October 14, 2010

Print Viewing Response


 Graciela Iturbide’s image of the woman with boombox and trailing hair.

         In the black and white image of the rushing woman there is strong contrast between the dark tones of her upper body and the white sky against which she stands out as a near silhouette. The subjects are of rich and varied texture, from the rough rock and dried leaves of a bush in the foreground to the thick cloth of the woman’s skirt and her soft flowing hair in the middle ground. Mountains recede into the background, and the repetition of small plants fills the expanse of the right side of the image. The woman’s arms are raised up and bits of sky peak out from beneath them. One side of the boombox she is carrying is illuminated by the sun, casting a small triangle shadow on her skirt. Her dark hand holds the boombox as naturally as it does the other unrecognizable object in her left hand which creates a sense of mystery in the image.
         My first impression was excitement and a sense of peace. I love the vantage point of rounding a corner with the woman and the space opening up. Because we are coming from a familiar place and a human scale and moving into a flat plane I feel that she is leading me somewhere. She is both grounded- rising organically from the rocks and completely in motion. I want to touch her hair and the folds of her skirt which are like petals of a flower.
          The woman is hurrying somewhere, she goes with purpose. Her posture connotes resolve- she is forging ahead as if nothing could stand in her way. The folds of her skirt are slightly billowing with her movement and also perhaps a slight gust of wind has blown her hair back as she rounds the bend. Maybe she is bringing music to the quiet desert. The artist created this image to show the woman whose presence is natural but at ease with an object of technology, of music. Music is as old as civilization, as old as birds. But the boombox is new, and without it the photograph could not be dated. Something I learned from this work that I could apply to my own is that it is okay to preserve a sense of mystery and leave the audience with a question. This image does not even show the subject’s face yet her demeanor, her determination, and her poise are perfectly communicated. I would love to make an image that is so beautiful and whose formal elements are so strong that it allows for the life of the image- its essence and purity- to resonate.


Tuesday, October 5, 2010

War Photographer


“The only way I can justify my role is to have respect for the other person’s predicament. The extent to which I do that is the extent to which I become accepted by the other, and to that extent I can accept myself.” –Jim Nachtwey

                                                          "My Soul Cannot Rest"

Jim Nachtwey is a witness to human suffering, he is a recorder of injustice. The poignancy of his images resides in the smoldering anguish and sorrow, the wailing, weeping...tears that would never cease. The dichotomy is the pure emotion and the aftermath- what happens when one runs out of tears-when the crying becomes a hiccup and finally stops. The viewer wonders how the subject could have moved on with such deep physical and emotional scars, but life continues, and these people have chosen survival. The man who is maimed will live to see his children grow up right, to help his wife, to live with dignity. Nachtwey’s photographs give a voice to the humanity of the unseen.
 The quote, “Normal codes of behavior are suspended in war” summarizes both the atrocious acts committed during wartime and Jim Nachtwey’s access to photograph them. The gravity of Nachtwey’s images comes from two ideas- carnal (having to do with the body) and carnage. One of the ways we connect to other people is through our understanding of the body- it’s basic processes and needs. However when the body is no longer  ‘complete’, when it is maimed or mutilated we notice immediately and we might see the person as less like us or even ‘less human’. Nachtwey forces us to recognize this idea we hold and invites us to engage in the deeper question of what makes us a person.
The images of famines depict frightening, skeletal, almost un-human creatures. They are the gaunt, cadaverous, wasted, rawboned, withered, passing away- the nearly dead.  The photograph that stuck with me the most was the emaciated men crawling on all fours, where even the basic evolutionary trait of bipedalism has regressed to conserve energy. His skin stretches over his bones in the same way the thin woven mats drape over the wooden supports on the house. He is wearing no clothes, which in addition to his posture increases our sense of his desperation and animal nature. He seems so near to death- lacking possessions, clothes, even bodily flesh and this makes him mystic and terrifying. A sense of urgency lurches at us to feed him, to clothe him, to ‘give him back’ his humanity (which is the question).  His desperation is our panic, our lurching stomachs and watering eyes. It is not without a sense of fear that we would look into the man’s eyes. Could we digest that amount of longing, pain, or worse yet- total acceptance of his fate- slipping away into the great unknown.
 In addition to the carnal, relating to the physical/ animal aspect to us, is carnage or the flesh of slain men, a great and unusual slaughter and injury. The sickening feeling that comes from seeing a disfigured person and their broken body, raises the question that when everything is taken away, when the body is so close to death-is that person less human? We are haunted by the image, but it is not shock alone that draws us to them and could by itself be ‘othering’, it is that recognition of their (and our own) most basic human nature.  It is with an understanding of the injustice and especially their willingness to be photographed by Nachtwey that conveys they are still human. Their awareness of their situation is constant, perhaps it is this that communicates with us what it is to be human.
Nachtwey has developed a method of working through the situations he photographs. There exists an openness to the event, and a deep understanding/acceptance of his role as witness and recorder. He has his own ‘library of suffering’ in his head and from this library he can connect to his subjects while still staying centered within himself. In order to complete his work he must be mentally prepared and completely present, which means not acquiescing to his emotions. Nachtwey must act as a camera- merely absorbing information and the emotions of others within a framework of understanding the way events play out. His effectiveness is not in his deep empathy, although that is crucial to gaining the trust of his subjects, but in his ability to deal with fear and channel his emotions into the strength of an image. The opposite of maim is to cure, heal, remedy, fix, mend, or rebuild. The process of witnessing the atrocities and the suffering of people and recording it can facilitate the healing or at least open a dialogue to negotiate peace, as Nachtwey does, by seeing ourselves in ‘the other’.

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Proposal 2: Artists in their Studios


Purpose


The artist studio is an intimate place where objects and ideas are forged and technical and creative hurdles are overcome. I want to see the creative process in progress in the space that the artist has chosen for that purpose. I am interested in seeing the routines, “off-task” and seemingly mundane or meditative practices of artists in their studios. This project seeks to uncover the relationship between artist and room, artist and materials, and artist and his or her creation. The images of the dirt, grime, order, obsessive-compulsive, caffeine, nicotine, the steady and unsteady hand guiding the work that we see.

Techniques
A.   I will be using a Nikon D40 to shoot and the project and display it as prints.
B.    I would like to both frame the artist within the space by using the ceiling height and walls, as well as more detailed images of the artists and their work to decrease the scale and capture the intimate moment when idea goes through the hand and into the medium.
      C.  I have access to photograph at least 3 artists in Tucson and more in Phoenix.

Significance
The process of making art can easily be overlooked when presented with the final product, I would like to capture artists at work and their unique way of inhabiting their space and their relationship with their materials.

History
No history exists thus far with the project, I have thought before about photographing artists who live in warehouses and their need to make the space ‘personal’ by adding ‘homey’ touches to the otherwise barren, out of proportion, generally dark world. 


Plan of Work: 


I will ask permission to photograph artists in their studios, I would like to begin with at least five artists and then select the most favorable, or perhaps juxtapose the different experiences of creators in studios. I will be able to start working on the photographs immediately and work evenings after five, Sundays, and three mornings a week starting in a month. I believe that I will end up working mostly with Tucson artists unless I have the ability to drive down to Phoenix and photograph the artists I know in their warehouses. 

Expected Results

I expect a body of work that explores the emotions and actions of artists in their creative havens. My concerns for the project are that artists may feel uncomfortable at first with another person being in their studio, they may act unnaturally or not feel the urge or ability to work normally.  


Budget
I only anticipate paying for gas money to get to the studios, and the occasional compensation for the artist in the form of coffee, cigarettes, or food.

Proposal 1: Motels


Purpose


I am interesting in exploring the trash left behind by people staying at motels as well as the cleaning crews that restore rooms to their ‘natural order’. I want to photograph the room after the customer leaves it and as the cleaning crew is working. Motels seem to be anonymous places, with an almost identical set up- beds with polyester comforters, cheap carpet, a bedside table with a bible inside, and mass market paintings, in this artificial environment events play out and the ‘aftermath’ in the form of stains, trash, and personal belongs can tell stories about the past inhabitants.

Techniques
A.   A. I will be using a Nikon D40 to capture the images, and I will exhibit the images as prints, at the present time I do not see the benefit of a slideshow but I will record the ambient sounds of the cleaning crews for possible use.
B.   B.  I am unsure what kinds of beautiful objects I will be able to find in a cramped room, where valuables are not laid out lest they be stolen. I would like to pair the realism of the trash with small moments of beauty, the glow of the light or organic patterns that form by accident in the bed sheets or a clump of hair in the drain.
C.    C. I do not yet have access to regularly photograph this project. I would need to ask permission from the motel’s manager and the cleaning workers. This could present a problem if the cleaning workers are not legal residents and fear their names or likeness used. A question I have is when the rooms would be cleaned, if checkout is during the afternoon then would cleaning always occur around the same time, does my schedule permit me to leave school and document this time, or does cleaning happen throughout the day depending on whether people have late checkout. I have all day Sunday to photograph, and after 5 the rest of the week.

Significance:
People feel a sense of anonymity in motels, and it allows them to act in ways they might not normally act. A motel is a place you do not have to make your bed, but I want to photograph the people that do. The significance of the project is to show a place ‘in between’ its normal use and the dialogue between worker and room.


History
: 

This is the very beginning of the project for me.  

Plan of Work: 


I will go scout out motels along Miracle Mile and Oracle and speak with the managers about the project and what kinds of access I can get. I initially want to begin with three or more motels and continue the project with one or two that have the most consistent material or subjects. I will speak with the cleaning crews and get their permission to be photographed. For the next four weeks I will only be able to photograph mornings on Sundays, as well as Monday through Thursday after five pm. After that I will be able to start shooting mornings three days a week as well as evenings.

Expected Results
:
I would like photographs of trash, the bedroom and bathroom, as well as portraits of the workers.  I anticipate 20 prints that explore the relationship between people and their work space. Their job is to clean up as best they can, the indication of past inhabitants. In a way, the room is second hand in that it is intimate to a person for a time (just like a shirt that was worn by someone else), however it is also not personal property but
another realm where we let ourselves forget all the other people that slept in the same bed and all the unseen acts that occurred there- from the most mundane to the most vile.
I fear feeling like an outsider to the cleaning crew, my Spanish is not good enough yet to communicate completely.

Budget:
I do not anticipate any costs outside of gas money to get to the motels, and the cost of rubber gloves used in inspecting trash, I do not think the budget will be a concern.


Wednesday, September 8, 2010

10 Images to Bring to Space


    


The images I chose hold no intrinsic value, they are not specific to me but their forms are symbolic. I wanted figures that could be used as an alphabet, as a cast of characters with which to depict stories, memories, meaning and forge a language of interpretation for my new life.

These forms, while mostly impersonal, capture concepts that I thought would become obsolete in a small empty room- such as the simple act of looking up, textures and other tactile experiences, daylight and expanse, the shadow/shell aspect to a body, an appreciation of the body, and a text which I could read and was coupled with a few objects forged from the earth. The box contains symbols of social practices that I would no longer have a chance to participate in such as marriage, travel, music, unhealthy vices, and art. The last photograph is the unknown, pure form which would resonate with me to a greater degree in a void of interaction. I see the content of these images not as important, but as tools with which to explore inner/outer space.